You are here

Drakes Bay Oyster Co. Seeks TRO To Keep Point Reyes National Seashore Oyster Farm In Business

Share

Politics stalked the national park system throughout 2007. From snowmobiles in Yellowstone to off-road vehicles in Big Cypress, it seemed natural resources and careful stewardship were trumped too often.

We heard both National Park Service Director Mary Bomar and Interior Secretary Dirk Kempthorne promise that science and careful stewardship would rule the national parks, and yet it seemed those promises fell short.

Not all the news surrounding the parks was negative, though. Congress approved President Bush's hefty funding increase for the parks, the National Park Foundation held a summit to explore partnership and philanthropy in the parks, and the Centennial Challenge was launched.

That said, here's a look at some of the top stories that rippled across the national park system in 2007:

  • Yellowstone snowmobiles. Despite scientific reports that detailed how snow coaches were the best alternative for Yellowstone's environment, wildlife, employees and visitors, park Superintendent Suzanne Lewis approved a plan to allow as many as 540 snowmobiles per day into Yellowstone. That decision, which conservation groups have promised to test in court, could have consequences far beyond Yellowstone and Grand Teton national parks as I noted back in November.

    Rick Smith, of the Coalition of National Park Service Retirees, speaks of decision (1:00)
    Get the Flash Player to heard this audio.

  • Fran Mainella points finger at Interior Department. A year after leaving her job as director of the National Park Service, Fran Mainella told the Traveler that Interior Department officials, not her office, called the shots on allowing snowmobiles in Yellowstone National Park.

    Fran Mainella talks to the 'Traveler' (4:34)
    Get the Flash Player to see hear the audio.

  • Jet skis. Conservation groups asked the Park Service to reinstate bans against personal watercraft in Gulf Islands and Cape Lookout national seashores as well as Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore. If the agency balks, the groups say they'll take it to court over the matter.

  • ORVs in Big Cypress National Preserve. A decision by Big Cypress Superintendent Karen Gustin to reopen 20 miles of off-road vehicle routes was greeted by a lawsuit just before Christmas when a coalition of groups filed a lawsuit to overturn that decision.

  • Katmai Bear Hunt. A groundswell of public outrage greeted the annual hunt of brown bears in Katmai National Preserve. Though hunting technically is allowed in the preserve, the seeming habituation of bears to humans created the impression that the bear hunt was akin to "shooting fish in a barrel" and prompted calls for the Park Service to end the hunt. Watch Video

  • Park Service budget. President Bush proposed, and Congress approved, a hefty funding increase for the National Park Service. True, the $2.39 billion FY08 budget cannibalizes some sections of the agency's budget so its base operations funding will rise $153.4 million. But an increase is an increase.

  • Centennial Challenge. In his fiscal 2008 budget request, President Bush proposed a Centennial Challenge with visions of infusing $3 billion, in a mix of public and private funding, into the park system as the National Park Service moves towards its centennial in 2016. Though controversial on several fronts, and falling short of his 2000 campaign promise to spend $5 billion to wipe out the Park Service's maintenance backlog, the initiative gained congressional approval, though not exactly as the president requested it.

    Kempthorne Announces Centennial Projects; Podcast (10:50)
    Get the Flash Player to see hear the audio.

  • National Park Foundation Leadership Summit on Partnership and Philanthropy. Private philanthropy long has played a crucial role in the construction and health of the national park system. To explore how philanthropy and partnerships can bolster the parks as they head to the National Park Service's centennial in 2016, the National Park Foundation in October convened a summit in Austin, Texas, to examine the possibilities.

    NPS Director Mary Bomar addresses Leadership Summit (1:45)
    Get the Flash Player to hear this audio.

  • The Demise of the National Parks Pass. This much-loved $50 pass, which got its holder into as many parks as they wanted for a year, died on January 1 when the $80 America the Beautiful Pass came to be. However, congressional efforts towards the end of 2007 could spur the return of the National Parks Pass.

  • Climate Change. In a telling report, the Government Accountability Office said the Interior Department has failed to provide the National Park Service with the tools it needs to cope with climate change and its impacts on the national park system.

Comments

One thing in listening to the game commission hearing today is that it appears the lease for the racks is dependent on there being an on shore lease. That was one of the items that people were asking the commission to change. The went in Exec session so the discussion wasn't public but came out and said they were taking no action.


ecbuck:
One thing in listening to the game commission hearing today is that it appears the lease for the racks is dependent on there being an on shore lease. That was one of the items that people were asking the commission to change. The went in Exec session so the discussion wasn't public but came out and said they were taking no action.

Without the shore operations it frankly wouldn't make much financial sense to operate. It would take too much time and use too much fuel to haul oysters from Drakes Estero to some other place.

However, the one thing I thought that might be a possibility is that a judge rules that only the State of California has the authority to order out the oyster racks since they lease the water allocations. That would probably only delay the final outcome if there are no shore operations nearby.

I'm a landlord myself. If I rent to someone and I have terms in a lease that my tenant violates, it would be up to me to enforce those terms. An upset neighbor doesn't have the authority to enforce our lease. That would be my argument with regard to the oyster racks. Even if the CFGC doesn't decouple the water bottom leases from the federal reservation, I believe it's still up to the State of California to evict. That would be how I've understood contract law.


It might not look to us like the financials would work but that was what the Lunny's lawyer was arguing for.


So depressing. The museum model of national park and wilderness management makes it likely our kids will regard these places as as alien as the far side of the moon. Back to the video game!

In Cape Verde's Parque Natural de Fogo, there's a winery within the park boundaries and inside the volcanic crater that's the park centerpiece. Also, people live inside the park and practice traditional economic activities. It hasn't destroyed the parklike nature of the place, as I discovered last spring. Here are some online pictures (not mine):

http://www.superstock.com/stock-photography/FOGO+ISLAND?pagenum=1 (many pictures of the park and its facilities, some showing its residents)

http://www.superstock.com/preview.asp?image=1848-703466&imagex=140&id=19... (the winery itself)

This could never happen here; instead, we pretend that these places are "untrammeled," which they never were.


imtnbke:

I believe past NPS Director George Hartzog Jr would agree with you, strongly! This is what he fumed when similar NPS efforts were directed toward NPS Hubbell Trading Post: "No way was the trading post on the Navajo Reservation going to be "another goddamned dead embalmed historic site." Congress agreed, and the agency's mandate was to manage Hubbell Trading Post as a living, breathing trading post with an authentic Indian trader running the place. Sadly, in recent years this and several other Icons in the Intermountain Region have been castrated to fit the modern NPS model. The whole saga of Billy Malone and Hubbell Trading post was chronicled on Kurt's site here. It's a pattern that I believe and have a sense that a significant number inside NPS would be relieved to see changed (Below SES ranks).

Served as NPS Director: George B. Hartzog, Jr., January 9, 1964 - December 31, 1972


Thanks, trailadvocate. That is most interesting indeed.


Bad PR (at the very least), Secretary Salazar. It takes a good man to say he was mistaken and lead.

http://www.sfgate.com/science/article/Drakes-Bay-fans-load-up-on-oysters...



Add comment

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

The Essential RVing Guide

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

The National Parks RVing Guide, aka the Essential RVing Guide To The National Parks, is the definitive guide for RVers seeking information on campgrounds in the National Park System where they can park their rigs. It's available for free for both iPhones and Android models.

This app is packed with RVing specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 parks.

You'll also find stories about RVing in the parks, some tips if you've just recently turned into an RVer, and some planning suggestions. A bonus that wasn't in the previous eBook or PDF versions of this guide are feeds of Traveler content: you'll find our latest stories as well as our most recent podcasts just a click away.

So whether you have an iPhone or an Android, download this app and start exploring the campgrounds in the National Park System where you can park your rig.